New York has both large dairy plants and small farmstead creameries. The makers below sell from their own sites. Soft cheeses and peak-summer heat can affect shipping; read each shop’s policy.
Corfu
Yancey’s Fancy
Artisan cheeses made in Corfu, New York. The plant in town dates to 1947; the Yancey’s Fancy name was adopted in 1998. The official site sells blocks, gift crates, and related items, and notes U.S. shipping limits (including that they do not ship to Alaska or Hawaii).
Visit the official site
Interlaken, Finger Lakes
Lively Run Dairy
A goat dairy in Interlaken making fresh chèvre, Cayuga Blue, and other goat cheeses. Shop and farm information are on the official site.
Visit the official site
Goshen
5 Spoke Creamery
Barbara and Alan’s creamery on a restored dairy farm in Goshen, New York, making raw-milk cheeses in a farmhouse aging room. The official site lists current cheeses (including Crawford, Browning Gold, and others) and shipping policy.
Visit the official site
New York goat dairy
Coach Farm
A New York producer of fresh and aged goat cheeses, plus goat yogurt and milk. The official site has products, recipes, and where-to-buy information.
Visit the official site
New York City shop
Murray’s Cheese
A well-known New York City cheese shop and classroom (not a farm). Murray’s sells cheeses from many regions, including New York, alongside others from elsewhere — so this is a NYC place to buy cheese, not a claim that every piece in the case is made in New York.
Visit the official site
More gift guides
2026 holiday gifts
Food & drink
NY-made pantry
Made-in-NY kitchen
New York maple
Finger Lakes wine country
Art & local gifts
Adirondack / outdoors
NYC-made