Part of the Live Finger Lakes networkExplore the region ›

NY-made pantry

A made-in-New-York pantry

Mustard from Buffalo, maple from the Hudson Valley, juice from Geneva, coffee roasted upstate, and chocolate made in the city — the makings of a New York pantry box.

Pantry gifts are the easiest New York gifts to ship: no alcohol rules, and usually no ice packs. Each maker below sells from its own site; check current products and shipping there. We do not list prices.

Buffalo

Weber’s Brand

A Buffalo condiment maker whose horseradish mustard is a Western New York staple. Mustard and related products are sold from the official site.

Visit the official site

Dover Plains, Hudson Valley

Crown Maple

Estate maple syrup from an 800-acre organic farm at Madava Farms, established in 2010. Bottles and gift collections are on the official shop.

Visit the official site

Geneva, Finger Lakes

Red Jacket Orchards

Three generations of the Nicholson family have farmed in the Finger Lakes; the company presses juices from apples it grows and sources locally. Products and where to buy are on the official site.

Visit the official site

Millerton and New York City

Irving Farm New York

A New York coffee company with a Millerton location and New York City cafes. Coffee and subscriptions are sold on the official site.

Visit the official site

Finger Lakes region

Finger Lakes Coffee Roasters

A roaster that says it has been roasting in the Finger Lakes for more than 25 years, with single origins, blends, and flavored coffees on its official shop.

Visit the official site

New York City, since 1923

Li-Lac Chocolates

Manhattan’s oldest chocolate house, still making chocolate in New York City, with a factory at Industry City in Brooklyn.

Visit the official site

Syracuse-born

Dinosaur Bar-B-Que

Bottled sauces and merch from the official site of this New York barbecue restaurant. Confirm current shop items and shipping limits there.

Visit the official site

Statewide marketplace

Shop Taste NY

The official online shop of the state’s Taste NY program, with a rotating selection of New York-produced food, beverages, and gifts.

Visit the official site

Pantry-box extras

If you are packing the box yourself, these Amazon searches cover the non-food pieces. They are not New York products.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Amazon links on this page use the site tag and are disclosed on the disclosure page.

More food makers are on food & drink, maple, and cheese.

More gift guides

2026 holiday gifts Food & drink Made-in-NY kitchen New York maple New York cheese Finger Lakes wine country Art & local gifts Adirondack / outdoors NYC-made

A Live Finger Lakes network site